CALL TODAY FOR A FREE CASE EVALUATION
In 1950, in Feres v. United States, 340 U.S. 135, the Supreme Court held that the United States is not liable under the Federal Tort Claims Act for injuries to service members that arise out of activity incident to military service. Courts have applied that rule to medical malpractice at military hospitals. As a result, active-duty service members generally cannot sue the government for negligent military medical care.
The doctrine has been widely criticized by judges, scholars, and service members. The Supreme Court reaffirmed it in United States v. Johnson, 481 U.S. 681 (1987). In 2025, the Court declined to reconsider it, over a dissent by Justice Thomas. Congress responded in part by creating an administrative claim process for active-duty medical malpractice, often called the Stayskal Act.
Veterans injured by VA care after discharge
Anyone suing a civilian doctor, hospital, or nursing home, including TRICARE network providers
Military spouses and children, for their own medical care
Military retirees
Reserve and National Guard members whose injury was not incident to their service
Active-duty service members injured by military medical care
Reserve and National Guard members injured while on duty in a way incident to their service
An administrative claim to the Department of Defense for malpractice in a covered military hospital or clinic
A California lawsuit against civilian doctors and hospitals who treated them, with a jury
Military and VA disability benefits, which are separate from a malpractice claim
Many families are told “you can’t sue the military” and give up. That is often wrong. The Feres doctrine is narrower than most people think. A spouse hurt during childbirth at a military hospital, a retiree misdiagnosed at a military clinic, a veteran neglected in a VA nursing home, and an active-duty Marine injured by a civilian surgeon may all have claims. The right path depends on who was hurt and where the care happened.
Has Congress repealed the Feres doctrine?
No. Congress created the administrative claim process for active-duty medical malpractice but did not repeal the doctrine. Proposals to change it are introduced from time to time, and we follow them.
Is my case “incident to service”?
It depends on the facts. Duty status, location, and the nature of the care all matter. Let us review your situation.
Does the Feres doctrine apply to a VA hospital?
Generally not for veterans treated after discharge. Veterans can bring a Federal Tort Claims Act claim for negligent VA care.
Do not assume you have no case. Call Jasinska Law Firm Professional Corporation at 866-248-0535 or email eliza@jasinskalaw.com.
Jasinska Law Firm Professional Corporation
1119 S. Mission Rd., #201, Fallbrook, CA 92028
Tel: 866-248-0535 | Fax: 866-248-0085 | eliza@jasinskalaw.com